Appearance
question:Can you make a complete list of sysctl settings on Linux that change a tcp connection timing or waiting in different cases. Make a short comment to each setting on what it affects and what's parameter is better in case of a server efficiency of maintaining 1000000 simultaneous connections and what's better to maintain a maximum throughout of a single connection?
answer:Creating an exhaustive list of all `sysctl` settings related to TCP timing or waiting, along with their effects and optimal values for large numbers of simultaneous connections vs. maximum throughput of a single connection, would be quite extensive. However, I can list some of the most significant settings: 1. `net.ipv4.tcp_fin_timeout` - Affects the time (in seconds) a socket remains in FIN-WAIT-2 state. - Many connections: lower value (frees up resources faster). - Max throughput: default value is often adequate. 2. `net.ipv4.tcp_keepalive_time` - Duration (in seconds) a connection needs to be idle before TCP starts sending keepalive probes. - Many connections: increase (reduces overhead). - Max throughput: default or lower if the connection is expected to be long-lived. 3. `net.ipv4.tcp_keepalive_probes` - Number of unacknowledged probes to send before considering the connection dead. - Many connections: increase (tolerates more temporary network issues). - Max throughput: default is usually fine. 4. `net.ipv4.tcp_keepalive_intvl` - Interval (in seconds) between TCP keepalive probes. - Many connections: increase (less frequent probing). - Max throughput: default or lower if fine-grained checking is necessary. 5. `net.ipv4.tcp_retries2` - Number of times to retry before killing an alive TCP connection. - Many connections: possibly increase (allows connections to survive longer during network instability). - Max throughput: default or lower for faster failure recognition. 6. `net.ipv4.tcp_syn_retries` - Number of times TCP will attempt to retry sending a SYN packet. - Many connections: default is usually fine. - Max throughput: default or lower for quicker failure recognition. 7. `net.ipv4.tcp_synack_retries` - Number of SYN+ACK packets retransmitted during the three-way handshake before the socket is marked as down. - Many connections: default is usually fine. - Max throughput: default or lower for quicker failure recognition. 8. `net.core.netdev_max_backlog` - Maximum number of packets in the queue of a network interface. - Many connections: increase (allows more packets to be queued for processing). - Max throughput: increase to ensure high bandwidth packets are not dropped. 9. `net.ipv4.tcp_max_syn_backlog` - Max number of remembered connection requests, which have not received an acknowledgment yet. - Many connections: increase (allows more pending connections). - Max throughput: default or higher if expecting high rates of new connections. 10. `net.ipv4.tcp_tw_reuse` - Allows reusing sockets in TIME-WAIT state for new connections when it's safe to do so. - Many connections: enable (1) (reduces TIME-WAIT socket count). - Max throughput: might not significantly affect single connection throughput. 11. `net.ipv4.tcp_tw_recycle` - Enable fast recycling of TIME-WAIT sockets. Note that this option is removed in modern Linux kernels due to causing issues with NAT. - Many connections: disabled or used with caution if on older kernels (can cause problems with NAT). - Max throughput: usually better disabled. 12. `net.ipv4.tcp_slow_start_after_idle` - Restart window probing after idle period (RFC 2861). - Many connections: disable (might improve performance when connections are frequently idle). - Max throughput: enable to ensure proper congestion control. 13. `net.ipv4.tcp_window_scaling` - Enable window scaling as per RFC 1323. - Many connections: enable (1) (allows larger windows and can improve performance). - Max throughput: enable (1) (necessary for efficient use of high bandwidth connections). 14. `net.core.rmem_max` and `net.core.wmem_max` - Max receive/send buffer size. - Many connections: adjust carefully to prevent memory exhaustion. - Max throughput: increase to allow larger buffers, which can improve throughput on high-latency or high-bandwidth connections. These settings can significantly alter the behavior of your TCP stack, and they should be tailored to your specific use case. Some settings might have different optimal values depending on the kernel version, network conditions, and the characteristics of your server's workload. Always test the changes in a controlled environment before applying them to production systems. Moreover, for managing such a high number of connections efficiently, other improvements like using a reverse proxy, load balancer, or tuning the application code itself can also play a significant role.
question:Aren't there other options relating to tcp timing or waiting?
answer:Yes, there are indeed other `sysctl` options related to TCP timing or waiting that may influence connection behavior. Here are a few additional ones: 15. `net.ipv4.tcp_reordering` - Maximum number of packets allowed to be out of order before the kernel starts to consider packets as lost and perform retransmissions. - Many connections: default or slightly higher value to accommodate varying network conditions. - Max throughput: default typically strikes a balance between robustness and performance. 16. `net.ipv4.tcp_retrans_collapse` - Allow TCP to collapse retransmitted segments over the original data in some situations. - Many connections: enable (1) for efficiency. - Max throughput: enable (1) for better handling of retransmissions. 17. `net.ipv4.tcp_rfc1337` - Implements the behavior recommended in RFC 1337 to prevent TIME-WAIT assassination hazards. - Many connections: enable (1) for improved stability in certain network conditions. - Max throughput: enable (1) typically does not affect throughput but can affect connection stability. 18. `net.ipv4.tcp_sack` - Enable Selective ACKnowledgment (SACK), which allows the receiver to inform the sender about all segments that have arrived successfully, so only the missing segments need to be retransmitted. - Many connections: enable (1) for better network performance. - Max throughput: enable (1) to ensure efficient loss recovery. 19. `net.ipv4.ip_local_port_range` - Range of local ports that TCP and UDP can use for outbound connections. - Many connections: widen the range to reduce the chance of port exhaustion. - Max throughput: default or widened as required based on connection attempts. 20. `net.ipv4.tcp_max_tw_buckets` - Maximum number of sockets in TIME-WAIT state. If exceeded, the system will start destroying them, potentially causing a loss of data. - Many connections: increase to prevent dropping connections, but be mindful of memory usage. - Max throughput: default typically suffices as it doesn't directly affect throughput. 21. `net.ipv4.tcp_abort_on_overflow` - Whether to abort a connection if the listen queue overflows. - Many connections: disable (0) if preferring clients to retry instead of facing immediate rejection. - Max throughput: default or disable depending on how critical it is to maintain every potential connection. 22. `net.ipv4.tcp_orphan_retries` - Number of times to retry before deciding that nobody is interested in the orphaned connection and resetting it. - Many connections: increase to prevent premature termination. - Max throughput: default is appropriate; too high may waste resources on unusable connections. 23. `net.core.somaxconn` - Maximum number of requests queued to a listen socket. - Many connections: increase to support a higher rate of incoming connections. - Max throughput: default or increase if a large number of simultaneous incoming connections is expected. 24. `net.ipv4.tcp_no_metrics_save` - Enable to prevent caching of metrics on a per route basis (might prevent some optimizations). - Many connections: Slightly disable (0) to maintain cached metrics. - Max throughput: Leave enabled (1) to allow TCP to make better decisions about routing. The effects of tweaking these settings may be subtle, and they can interact with each other in complex ways. Some Linux distributions might change defaults or introduce new settings to improve TCP performance. Always refer to the latest Linux kernel documentation for the most accurate information regarding these settings. When optimizing TCP settings, incremental changes and careful monitoring are crucial to ensure that modifications have the desired impact without causing unforeseen issues.
question:Are there others settings relating to tcp connection waiting?
answer:In addition to the settings already mentioned, there are other `sysctl` parameters that can influence TCP connection behaviors, particularly with regard to connection establishment, waiting, and retransmission timings. Here are some more TCP-related settings: 25. `net.ipv4.tcp_syncookies` - Enables TCP SYN cookies, which are used to prevent SYN flood attacks without dropping connections when the SYN queue is full. - Many connections: Enable (1) to safeguard against SYN flood attacks while handling many connections. - Max throughput: Having it enabled (1) does not normally impact a single connection's throughput. 26. `net.ipv4.tcp_mem` - Array of three integers that control how the TCP stack should behave when it comes to memory usage. It defines memory thresholds for triggering pressure moderation mechanisms. - Many connections: Tuned higher to allow the TCP stack to use more memory, which can be useful for managing a large number of connections. - Max throughput: Tuned based on available system memory to ensure buffer sizes are sufficient for optimal throughput without causing memory pressure. 27. `net.ipv4.tcp_wmem` and `net.ipv4.tcp_rmem` - Arrays of three integers, where the values are the minimum, initial/default, and maximum TCP send/receive buffer sizes. - Many connections: Carefully adjust to ensure that the networking stack does not exhaust the available memory. - Max throughput: Increase the max buffer size to allow the TCP stack to potentially use larger buffers for bandwidth-heavy connections. 28. `net.ipv4.tcp_low_latency` - Option to trade throughput for lower latency in TCP data transmissions. - Many connections: Default settings are typically fine, as are throughput considerations. - Max throughput: Set to 0 (disabled) to favor throughput over reduced latency. 29. `net.ipv4.tcp_congestion_control` - Defines the TCP congestion control algorithm used. - Many connections: Choose an algorithm like 'cubic' or 'htcp' that scales well with numerous connections and various RTTs. - Max throughput: 'cubic' or 'bbr' might be more effective depending on the network conditions and kernel version. 30. `net.ipv4.tcp_challenge_ack_limit` - Maximum number of challenge ACKs sent per second to prevent attacks involving the spoofing of TCP sessions. - Many connections: Default is typically adequate, but may be increased with caution. - Max throughput: Unlikely to impact a single connection's throughput as it pertains to security, not performance. 31. `net.ipv4.tcp_app_win` - Defines the applicative window reduction size. - Many connections: Typically left as default. - Max throughput: Typically left as default. 32. `net.ipv4.tcp_adv_win_scale` - Controls the ratio for adjusting the number of bytes the window can be decreased in an attempt to manage window shrinkage in receiver's buffer. - Many connections: Default values are usually appropriate. - Max throughput: Default values are usually appropriate. 33. `net.ipv4.tcp_max_orphans` - Sets the maximum number of orphaned sockets allowed system-wide. Orphaned sockets are not attached to any file descriptor and could result from an overwhelmed server. - Many connections: Increase to avoid premature termination of connections when the limit is too low for the traffic volume. - Max throughput: Default is typically fine; adjusting this impacts system resource usage more than throughput. It's important to remember that the values for these settings are highly dependent on your specific use case, system resources, kernel version, and networking environment. Changing these settings indiscriminately could lead to unintended consequences, so it's always best to make changes in a controlled environment and monitor their effects carefully. Given the nuances and complexity of TCP/IP tuning, when dealing with a large number of connections or optimizing for throughput, it might also be beneficial to consider other architectural choices such as load balancing, rate limiting, and using a high-performance kernel stack like those provided by cloud service providers.
question:Nothing to add in the context?
answer:As of my last update, the provided lists of `sysctl` settings cover a comprehensive range of TCP-related parameters that affect connection timing, waiting behavior, and management of resources relevant to TCP connections. However, it's important to consider the broader context when adjusting these settings: 1. **Operating System and Kernel Version:** Different Linux distributions and kernel versions may have unique defaults or additional `sysctl` options. Always check the current documentation for your specific environment. 2. **Network Stack Enhancements:** Modern Linux kernels include performance enhancements like TCP Fast Open (TFO), BBR congestion control, and more. These require their own specific sysctl settings and careful consideration if you're looking to leverage them. 3. **Networking Hardware:** The capabilities of your networking equipment (NICs, switches, routers) can also influence TCP performance. Look for hardware offloading features that can handle certain TCP functions more efficiently. 4. **Testing and Monitoring:** Any changes to TCP settings should be tested under conditions that closely resemble your production environment. Monitoring tools can provide insights into how these changes affect network performance. 5. **Scaling Architecture:** For use cases with a significant number of simultaneous connections, consider architectural solutions such as connection pooling, load balancing, reverse proxies, and distributed systems to ensure scalability. 6. **Security Implications:** Be aware that certain changes, while potentially improving performance, may have security implications (e.g., `tcp_syncookies` and `tcp_challenge_ack_limit`). 7. **Application Design**: The application layer can have a significant impact on connection management and performance. Optimizing code, using non-blocking I/O, and leveraging technologies like epoll can all contribute to improved handling of TCP connections. 8. **Resource Limits:** System-wide limits such as file descriptors and memory can impact how many connections can be supported regardless of TCP settings. Adjustments might be needed in `/etc/security/limits.conf` as well as ulimit settings. Given the interdependent nature of these factors, optimal configuration values for TCP settings cannot be provided in a one-size-fits-all manner. A careful analysis of the holistic environment, as well as an iterative approach to tuning with performance testing and monitoring feedback, is the recommended strategy. Please keep in mind that optimizing for one million simultaneous connections and for maximum throughput for a single connection might require mutually exclusive trade-offs. What works best for one scenario might not be optimal for the other, so if both goals are equally important, you may need to find a balance or implement context-aware configurations that can adjust settings dynamically based on the current workload characteristics.